Cupcakes in Conyers are serious business, which is weird, because Conyers isn’t exactly a cupcake metropolis. But the suburbs get hungry too.
Between the polished display cases of Nothing Bundt Cakes and a dessert trailer that smells like a waffle bar, this town runs the full bakery gamut. I ate a lot of frosting for this, and also learned that Smallcakes will hand you a moist cake with a side of attitude.
No foodie certifications here, just a local who knows his sugar. Read on.
Sip and Frost Cake Bar
☎️ +1678-480-5054
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Kind staff, great sweets |
| Cake decorating is fun |
| Perfect for families, friends |
| Warm, beautiful atmosphere |
| Banana pudding worth trying |
I went to Sip and Frost Cake Bar expecting cupcakes, which was probably my first mistake. They do have sweets, and the staff is kind, but the real show is the cake decorating. It is fun. Perfect for families or groups of friends who want to make a mess and call it art. The banana pudding is worth trying, though I'm not sure it counts as a cupcake. The atmosphere is warm and beautiful, assuming you like pastel colors and the smell of buttercream. I left with a sugar high and a vague sense that I should have asked for a cupcake specifically. Whatever. It was pleasant.
You might also want to check out the best places for lunch in Athens.
Nothing Bundt Cakes
☎️ +1470-227-9042
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Moist, flavorful cakes every time |
| Friendly, helpful staff consistently |
| One-stop shop for gifts |
| Great for celebrations or self-treats |
Nothing Bundt Cakes is a reliable operation, I will give them that. The cakes are moist and flavorful every single time, which sounds like faint praise until you've had a dry cupcake elsewhere. The staff is friendly and helpful, consistently, which is more than I can say for most places. It's a one-stop shop for gifts, so if you forgot a birthday and need something that looks like you put in effort, this is your place. Great for celebrations or self-treats. I mostly used it for the latter. The bundt shape is weird, but it works. No complaints, just satisfaction.
You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Johns Creek.
Queen Sheba Bakery
☎️ +1470-346-2952
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Red velvet cake rich and light |
| Bombolina light and fluffy |
| Best latte in a long time |
| Friendly, welcoming staff |
| Authentic Habeshan food worth trying |
Queen Sheba Bakery is a bit of a wild card. I went in for the red velvet cake, which is rich and light at the same time, a trick I still don't fully understand. The bombolina is light and fluffy, and I had the best latte I've had in a long time. The staff is friendly and welcoming, even when I asked what a bombolina was. They also have authentic Habeshan food worth trying, but I was there for cake. I should probably go back for the food, but the pastry case is distracting. If you like surprises, this is the place. I was surprised. In a good way.
You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Suwanee.
Smallcakes Stockbridge
☎️ +1678-759-1662
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Moist cupcakes, rude service |
| Pricey at $4.50 each |
| Beautiful cake store design |
| Consistent over the years |
| Better product elsewhere in chain |
Smallcakes Stockbridge has a beautiful cake store design, which is the nicest thing I can say. The cupcakes are moist, but the service is rude. I don't know why they're so grumpy. Maybe it's the price. At $4.50 each, you'd think they'd be nicer. I've been here over the years, and it's consistent, both in product and in attitude. There's a better product elsewhere in the chain, but if you're in Stockbridge and need a cupcake, this will do. Just don't expect a smile. Or a thank you. I got neither. The cake was fine though. That's something.
You might also want to check out the best burger in Athens.
Decadent Creations
☎️ +1770-833-8216
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Best vegan cupcakes in Conyers |
| Bakes fresh with short notice |
| Delivers exactly on time |
| Moist, delicious, and popular |
| Handles special orders flawlessly |
Decadent Creations is the best vegan cupcake place in Conyers, which I say with confidence because I've tried the others. They bake fresh with short notice, which is convenient if you're like me and plan everything at the last minute. They deliver exactly on time, which is a miracle in the food business. The cupcakes are moist and delicious, and they're popular for a reason. They handle special orders flawlessly. I ordered a dozen vegan chocolate cupcakes for a party, and no one noticed they were vegan. That's the highest compliment I can give. If you need a vegan cupcake, this is the place. If you don't, get one anyway.
You might also want to check out the best bbq restaurants in Athens.
Cupcake Garden Experience
☎️ +1678-597-8854
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Soft cakes, rich frostings |
| Staff is wonderfully patient |
| Tuesday four-plus dollar deal |
| Warm biscoff is superior |
| Worth every Conyers visit |
The Cupcake Garden Experience is worth every Conyers visit, and I mean that. The cakes are soft, and the frostings are rich, a combination that sounds simple but is hard to nail. The staff is wonderfully patient, which is good because I took forever to decide. They have a Tuesday deal for four-plus dollars, which is vague but cheap enough to ignore the details. The warm biscoff cupcake is superior to the cold version, so ask for it heated. I learned that the hard way. The texture changes, and it's better. Trust me. I'm a professional. Sort of. Anyway, go on a Tuesday and thank me later.
You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Dahlonega.
Brown Sugar Desserts
☎️ +1678-806-5511
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Moist, decadent chocolate cake |
| Quick, friendly service |
| Wide cupcake variety |
| Satisfying sweet tooth options |
Brown Sugar Desserts is a straightforward operation. They have moist, decadent chocolate cake, which is what I ordered, and it did not disappoint. The service is quick and friendly, which is all I ask for. They have a wide variety of cupcakes, so you can't say they don't have options. I tried the chocolate, obviously, and it satisfied my sweet tooth. That's really all I need. If you're looking for a place that gets the basics right, this is it. No frills, just good cake. I appreciate that. It's rare these days. I'll be back, mostly for the chocolate.
You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Bethlehem.
The SugarMill, Inc.
☎️ +1678-806-5377
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Top-notch customer service |
| Cakes match photos exactly |
| Moist, delicious pound cake |
| Red velvet worth trying |
The SugarMill, Inc. is a professional operation. The top-notch customer service is the first thing I noticed. They actually listen to you, which is more than I can say for some places. The cakes match the photos exactly, which is a relief because I've been burned before. The pound cake is moist and delicious, and the red velvet is worth trying. I got a slice of each, and I wasn't disappointed. The texture is spot on. If you're planning an event or just want a good cake, this is a safe bet. I'd say it's one of the best in Conyers. I don't say that lightly.
You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Lilburn.
Dreams Bakery Bar
☎️ +1770-728-5899
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Soft, fresh, flavorful cupcakes |
| Friendly, personal service |
| Fast but cozy experience |
| Desserts guests still request |
Dreams Bakery Bar is exactly what it sounds like, a bakery that serves dreams in the form of cupcakes. The cupcakes are soft, fresh, and flavorful, which is a good combination. The service is friendly and personal, so you feel like a regular even if it's your first time. It's a fast but cozy experience, which sounds contradictory, but it works. You're in and out quickly, but you feel like you've been there for a while. The desserts are so good that guests still request them at events. I had a red velvet, and I get why. It's solid. I'd go back.
You might also want to check out the best chinese restaurant in Athens.
Keys Cakery Dessert Trailer
☎️ +1678-498-9222
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Fantastic variety of options |
| Unique waffle bar available |
| Outstanding fresh lemonade |
| Wonderful, welcoming people |
| Desserts smell incredible |
Keys Cakery Dessert Trailer is a trailer, and that's part of the charm. They have a fantastic variety of options, so you won't get bored. The unique waffle bar is worth a mention, even if I didn't try it because I was there for cupcakes. The outstanding fresh lemonade is a nice counterpart to the sweets. The desserts smell incredible, which is a good sign before you even taste them. The people are wonderful and welcoming, which makes the experience better. I had a cupcake and a lemonade, and both were great. If you see the trailer, stop. You won't regret it.
You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Oakwood.
The SUGAR Dessert Bar
☎️ +1678-806-5480
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Friendly staff and clean |
| Fresh desserts, beautifully presented |
| Warm welcoming atmosphere |
| Worth returning to Conyers |
The SUGAR Dessert Bar is clean and friendly, which is a good baseline. The staff is friendly, and the place is clean, so you don't have to worry about hygiene. The desserts are fresh and beautifully presented, which is nice if you care about aesthetics. I do. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, so you feel comfortable taking your time. The cupcakes are good, but nothing blew my mind. It's solid, reliable, and worth returning to Conyers for. I had a vanilla cupcake with frosting, and it was fine. The presentation was the best part. If you're in the area, give it a shot.
You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Dacula.
Awesome Coffee Co & Ooey Gooey Bake Shoppe
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Cinnamon rolls worth returning for |
| Owner accommodated frosting-free request |
| Real matcha, not artificial syrup |
| Needed addition to Olde Town |
Awesome Coffee Co & Ooey Gooey Bake Shoppe is a needed addition to Olde Town, and I mean that. The cinnamon rolls are worth returning for, even if my review is about cupcakes. They also have cupcakes, which are good, but the owner accommodated my frosting-free request, which is a rare kindness. The real matcha is a plus, not that artificial syrup stuff. I had a green tea latte, and it was actually good. The service was friendly, and I left satisfied. It's a cozy spot with good coffee and baked goods. I'll be back for those cinnamon rolls. Maybe with frosting next time. Maybe not.
You might also want to check out the best brunch in Gainesville.


























